Ask a Lehigh Valley investor where the good buildings come from and the honest ones give you a name, not a website. James Reardon has spent the past decade buying and selling more than $250 million of multifamily and commercial real estate within an hour of Allentown, and the defining feature of that volume is where it did not happen: on a public listing. Inside the Lehigh Valley Private Equity Fund he is known, half in jest and entirely in earnest, as the "inventory monster." Around the market he has earned a shorter title. He is the Off-Market King. www.thejamesreardonteam.com
The number behind the name
Since LVPEF launched in July 2021, James has found every property the fund has bought: 150-plus units across Allentown, Bethlehem, Easton, Lansford and the surrounding towns, plus the medical office building at 529 W Broad Street in Bethlehem and the 950/960 Broadway strip center that signal the fund's push into commercial. The published portfolio reads like a map of his relationships: 139 S 8th Street (4 units and 6 garages), 514 N 15th Street (6 units), 114 S 8th Street (6 units), the 16-unit Susquehanna Apartments that returned roughly $530,000 in profit on exit. He also sources most of what The James Reardon Team's private clients buy. Across the two channels the team has touched $450 million-plus in transactions, and James is the common thread.
Why "off-market" is the whole story
A listed building is a building the whole market has already priced. An off-market building is one where the seller has chosen the buyer. James's edge is that for 10 years he has been the person sellers choose. Long-time Lehigh Valley owners, many with portfolios too large to sell in a single tax year, release their buildings to him one or two at a time. He matches each one to a buyer he already knows: the fund, or a doctor, lawyer, engineer or business owner with bank financing or cash in hand who wants the income and the depreciation. No bidding war, no listing photos, no 90 days on market. A phone call, a walk-through, a number that works for both sides.
Built from the deal, not the desk
James did not arrive at this from a sales training program. He has developed, managed and physically built real estate projects of his own, which is why his valuations hold up at the bank and his renovation budgets hold up on site. The James Reardon Team’s standing line is a description of how he has always worked “Most agents price property. We underwrite it.’’
Rent roll first, expenses second, financing sensitivity third, asking price last. Buyers who chase price get outbid. Buyers who chase the math, with James, close.
The decade in review
Ten years, $250 million, and a market that has gone from overlooked to overheated. Through all of it, James Reardon has done the unglamorous thing: shown up at the same kitchen tables, year after year, until the inventory came to him. That is how a title like Off-Market King gets earned, and why the people who hold it rarely need to say it themselves.
Connect With The James Reardon Team
For property owners considering selling and buyers seeking opportunities in the Lehigh Valley real estate market, The James Reardon Team offers access to extensive market knowledge, established relationships, and a proven track record in multifamily and commercial real estate transactions.
With a focus on off-market opportunities, property valuation, and strategic acquisitions, the team continues to connect qualified buyers with property owners while helping clients navigate transactions through a disciplined, relationship-driven approach.
Property owners interested in selling and prospective buyers looking to explore available opportunities can contact The James Reardon Team at 484-866-2495 or team@thejamesreardonteam.com to discuss their real estate goals, submit a property for consideration, or learn more about joining the team's private buyer network. www.thejamesreardonteam.com
The James Reardon Team is brokered by Steel City Realty in Easton PA. To submit a property or join the buyer list, call 484-866-2495 or email team@thejamesreardonteam.com. Investment offerings are made by separate entities and are not solicitations of brokerage.